Close this search box.

4 Ingredient, easy lemon meringue pie

easy lemon meringue pie
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure for more information.

Growing up in South Africa, we would only have lemon meringue pie on really special occasions. The traditional South African lemon meringue pie is very rich and decadent, so it is not a dessert you want to have regularly. The same trend is followed in our home today.

In our home, lemon meringue pie (and fudge) has to be made in secret. I have learned my lesson one-too-many times, so I don’t tell anyone what I’m making until it’s almost done. Otherwise, I’d have kids hanging around the kitchen, eager to get the first slice.

This particular pie has only 4 ingredients, with a store-bought crust being the 5th ingredient. It is very easy and beginner-friendly! 

As you will see from the short list of ingredients, this is not a gelatin kind of pie. No shade on those lemon meringue jello/gelatin pies but once you’ve had the recipe below, it’s really hard to love the jello/gelatin version.

5-Ingredient Easy Lemon Meringue Pie

Prep Time: 15mins | Cook Time: 15 mins | Servings: 8 | Difficulty: Easy

Lemon Meringue Pie Ingredients


1 can condensed milk
½ cup lemon juice
2 eggs, separated
3½ tablespoons powdered sugar

store-bought, prepared crust


  1. Preheat your oven to 350° Fahrenheit.
  2. Add the condensed milk to a bowl. 
  3. Add the lemon juice, little by little. Stir as you add.
  4. Separate the eggs. Add the yolks to the mixture, and stir.
  5. Stir the mixture into your prepared crust.
  6. Bake for 10 minutes in your preheated oven.
  7. TO MAKE THE MERINGUE: In a clean bowl, add the egg whites.
  8. With a hand mixer, beat the eggs. Gradually add the powdered sugar and beat until stiff peaks are formed.
  9. Spread meringue over the pie. Make sure to seal the edges at the crust. 
  10. Bake for an additional 15 minutes until the meringue is golden brown.
  11. Allow your lemon meringue pie to cool down before you slice and serve.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About The Author

Hi. We’re the Chelten’s. We visit South Africa 1-2 times per year, so we want to share our experiences with you so that you may make educated decisions when you plan your next trip to the rainbow nation.

Free Recipe eBooks
Want to have your business or product featured?

We’re always looking for awesome places, products, travel accessories, or anything else that promotes the rich and colorful culture of South Africa.
Contact Us

Recipe Categories
Most Watched
South African Goodies
Caffeine Free Red Rooibos Tea Bags 40 - Naturally Sweet Herbal Tea Safe for Children and Pregnant Women - Low Tannin, Premium Organic Rooibos Tea Sustainably and Ethically Farmed in South Africa
  • ❤️ SWEET AND HEALTHY – Our organic rooibos tea, one of the delightful South African gifts, has a mildly sweet flavor but it's sugar-free and...
  • ❤️ PREMIUM QUALITY ORGANIC TEA - We give our assurance that Rooibos Rocks Red Rooibos Tea is high-quality. Each of our biodegradable rooibos tea...
  • ❤️ SUSTAINABLY AND ETHICALLY GROWN - Our red tea from South Africa is grown without the use of synthetic pesticides, which is verified by our USDA...
  • ❤️ DELICIOUS HOT OR COLD - Whether you want your tea cold or hot, our caffeine free rooibos tea is delicious no matter what. It can be a thirst...
  • ❤️ EASY-TO-PREPARE ROOIBOS TEA - Packaged in handy tagless tea bags (2 stay-fresh foil pouches of 20). Drop one in your cup, mug or tea pot (1...
Nando's Hot Spicy Mayo PERinaise - Flavored Mayonnaise Spread & Dressing - Gluten Free - 8.6 fl oz (3 Pack)
  • HOT MAYO PERINAISE - Our gluten-free aioli hot mayonnaise is crafted with cage-free eggs and contains zero added MSG, artificial colors, or flavors....
  • AUTHENIC FLAVOR EXPERIENCE - Nandos Perinaise Mayo is more than just mayo. It's our famous PERi-PERi blended mayo that you've come to love in our...
  • SUSTAINABLY SOURCED CHILLIES - Every bottle of Nando's PERi-PERi sauce, basting, or marinade is made with chillies grown at PERi-Farms in Southern...
  • VERSILIE CONDIMENTS - This isn't your average mayo. For a taste of South African food and Portuguese food, use PERinaise as a spicy dip for chips and...
  • DELICIOUS FLAVORS - Our PERi-PERi chilli pepper, the African Bird's Eye chilli, is expertly blended with garlic, fresh lemons, and other delicious...
Biltong Depot - Natural Droewors (1 lb) 16oz South African Droewors Beef Sausage Sticks Keto and Paleo Certified Air-Dried Sausages - Whole 30 Approved, No Sugar, Gluten Free, No Nitrates - Healthy and Natural Snacks
  • Authentic South African Taste- Enjoy a traditional South African favorite! Our traditional Droewors is spiced with delicious flavors including...
  • Paleo and Keto Approved- You can’t go wrong with adding more protein in your diet, and what better way of getting that than with a savory indulgent...
  • All Natural- Our mouthwatering Droewors isn’t just delicious, it is also made with all natural and simple ingredients! Zero nitrates, zero MSG, zero...
  • More than just a Snack- Our Droewors gives a unique touch to traditional charcuterie boards! Pair it with your favorite wine, beer or spirit! Enjoy it...
  • Sharing is Caring- Our traditional Droewors is a total crowd pleaser! Gift our Droewors to your South African friends or convert your Slim Jim lovers!...